Table of Contents
The Top 10 Mystery Board Games
We understand how difficult it can be to select the best mystery board games but don’t worry because we’ve done all of the legwork for you. Furthermore, despite the fact that mystery murder board games dominate the market, we have included other intriguing mystery games in the listing.
The Top 10 Mystery Board Games
Our ranking is based on My Best’s research.
Similarly, our ranking may not be acceptable to everyone, so it is up to you to select the best one for you.
| Rank | Name of the Board Game | Price |
| 10 | Suspicion | $19.99 |
| 9 | Clue Retro Series 1986 | $19.99 |
| 8 | The Resistance | $18.60 |
| 7 | Death at the Dive Bar | $29.99 |
| 6 | Exit: The Sinister Mansion | $13.70 |
| 5 | 221B Baker Street | $47.51 |
| 4 | Mysterium | $43.97 |
| 3 | Salem | $24.99 |
| 2 | Deception: Murder in Hong Kong | $31.65 |
| 1 | Betrayal at the House on the Hill | $29.49 |
ten. Suspicion
In terms of the game, the plot revolves around a wealthy art collector’s masquerade party.
However, among the guests at the party is a jewel thief.
To find out who it is, the players will have to use their detective skills.
Furthermore, while the game is exciting, some reviewers complained that it became boring or too simple.
Other reviewers, on the other hand, praised the game’s simplicity and story plot.
According to the reviewers, it is a fun game for families with children to enjoy, and children under the required age can play it as well.
1986 Clue Retro Series
Our list would be incomplete if we did not mention the most well-known and one of the best mystery board games.
Furthermore, let us not forget that this game has been a success for 35 years.
Because the characters have memorable names, it is simple for children to play without difficulty.
In the game, we must identify the weapon, the chamber, and the perpetrator as Colonel Mustard or Mrs. Peacock.
The Opposition
The Resistance is ranked number eight.
This is one of the best mystery board games available for a reasonable price.
You can play as a spy or a member of the resistance in this game.
The resistance will have to carry out missions to overthrow the government, while the spies will do everything in their power to prevent this.
Nobody knows who the spy or rebel is.
One of the best features of this game is that, due to its small size, it is easy to transport if you are the one who brings it to the party.
Concerning the critics, some have expressed concern that the game’s mechanics rely heavily on people chatting and that silent players may become disoriented.
It was enjoyable, according to the other reviewers.
7. The Dive Bar’s Death
It was no surprise to see this one on the list of the best mystery board games.
In terms of the game, Hunt a Killer is a mystery board game created by the creators of the well-known murder mystery subscription box.
Unlike other games that use cards and boards, this one uses actual objects to immerse you as a true detective.
Unfortunately, once you’ve solved the riddle, you won’t be able to play the game. But it’s fantastic for special occasions!
Moving on to the critics, some are unhappy with the amount of reading required, claiming that it results in less debate.
This article may be of interest to you: 5 Best Cooperative Board Games For Family Fun.
The Sinister Mansion is the sixth exit
Most board games require more than one player to participate, but Exit can be played by one or up to four people.
This is what distinguishes Exit from the competition.
Players arrive at a haunted house to solve a mystery but become trapped within it.
To escape before time runs out, they must solve puzzles and find clues.
However, because we need to destroy some elements to find the answer, you can only play it once.
Some reviewers complain that the riddles are too difficult.
At the same time, other reviewers were captivated by the game’s plot and thrill.
5 Baker Street, 221B
This game is the best option for keeping participants from becoming overly competitive.
In other words, the participants are given a riddle that must be investigated through a series of clues in order to solve the case.
Furthermore, you can play the game in groups or alone.
Because there are 200 riddles, expect a lot of repetitions.
However, some reviews claimed that some game components were missing.
Other critics, on the other hand, complained that the rules were too simple.
Positive reviews also praise the game’s simplicity and straightforwardness.
four. mysticism
Mysterium is a good choice if you want to avoid competition while still having a large circle of friends to play with casually.
In terms of the game, it features characters who are all mediums or spirits who must work together to solve a crime at Warwick Manor.
Furthermore, the game changes depending on who is playing.
Nonetheless, the game is marketed for two to seven players; the standard rules apply to four and up.
Besides this, specific restrictions apply in two and three-player modes.
However, reviews indicate that the game takes a long time and a lot of space to set up.
Positive reviews, on the other hand, praise the game’s artwork and high-quality components.
3. Salem
If you enjoy fantasy, magic, and witchcraft, then this game is for you.
Salem, rated as one of the best mystery board games, is a witch hunt in which the witch could be any of your friends.
This game will make you distrust everyone because, while the majority of the participants are ordinary citizens, witches lurk among the masses, attempting to murder or convert the others in order to win the game.
However, critics pointed out that the rules are more difficult to understand.
However, the majority of respondents agreed that once you get the hang of it, it’s pretty addictive.
Even the nicest of your friends may become savage liars for 45 minutes.
2. Murder in Hong Kong: Deception
Moving on to the second board game, Deception is a lovely option if you prefer a shorter game.
The goal of the game is to find the perpetrator and the weapon used to commit the crime, which features a killer and a forensic scientist.
Each game lasts about 20 minutes, uses 250 cards, and is very simple and enjoyable to play.
Concerning the critics, they claimed that the game was too simple and that it wasn’t much fun with only a few players.
They suggested that having six or more players makes the game more enjoyable.
Also, read Kane Williamson, Six Longest NFL Games Ever, Top 10 Funniest Moments in History of Cricket
1. The House on the Hill is betrayed
For the best mystery board game, we have Betrayal at the House on the Hill.
This is a very popular game that keeps its players coming back for more.
Players attempt to find additional chambers in order to escape the ominous mansion on the hill.
At any time, one of the players turns a traitor. When a traitor is exposed, a story emerges.
As the traitors attempt to use their abilities to attack the entire squad, the team must work together to defeat the traitor.
Many players appear to be irritated by the game’s numerous rules.
Because the majority of them stated that they had to read them several times to understand them, others have stated that the subject is rather depressing, which may upset many people.
Other reviewers, on the other hand, praised the game for its excellent story plot and replayability.
When compared to other mystery board games, this one has received a lot of positive feedback.
